ARX Series 9 April 2020
Climate Change Integration in the Investment Process
Climate Change Integration in the Investment ProcessWatch the Webinar
Climate change presents a range of physical and transition risks for business and the financial industry. If commitments to limit global warming to 2°C (or less), as envisaged in the Paris Agreement, are to be fulfilled, then the coming decades will witness a tremendous diversion of investments from carbon-intensive industries towards renewable energy and other technologies focused on decarbonisation.
While the global investment community is increasingly becoming aware of the financial implications that climate-related risks possess, they need education and tools to analyse and mitigate these risks.
On 9 April 2020, CFA Institute Asia-Pacific Research Exchange (ARX) held a webinar on Climate Change and ESG Disclosures to discuss a few of the most pressing questions that financial professionals have to guide them in making effective decisions.
The Cause of Climate Change: It’s Us!
To kick off the webinar, Matthew Orsagh, senior director of Capital Markets Policy at CFA Institute, gave a brief presentation regarding climate change and how it can be integrated into the investment process. For centuries, greenhouse gases (GHGs) have played a major role in warming the planet and making it habitable. Without GHGs, the average temperature on Earth would be -18°C, compared with the actual average temperature of 15°. The past few decades, however, have witnessed a dramatic increase in average temperatures because of rising GHG concentrations. To put things into perspective, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), between 1880 and 2020, the seven warmest years have been recorded since 2014, while the 10 warmest years over the same period have been recorded since 2005.
Climate-Related Risks to Financial Stability
Investors need to focus on two types of climate-related risks: physical and transition risks. Physical risks involve economic losses that result from anthropogenic effects of climate change and extreme weather events, such as hurricanes, floods, and droughts. In contrast, transition risks include the financial impact on businesses that produce or rely on fossil fuel assets, such as coal, oil, and gas, which will lose their value because of policy measures and market trends to transition to a low-carbon economy.
What Can Finance Do?
Different approaches, such as carbon tax and cap-and-trade, can help reduce emissions, but these initiatives cover only 20% of the global emissions. We need a global carbon market to assess the real price of carbon. Once such a market exists, investors will be in a better position to determine the impact of climate-related risks on companies’ business. It is also important to use standard metrics and framework, such as the EU taxonomy, across the market to inform investors about the impact of their investments. Additionally, we should engage more with companies regarding climate-related risks and educate our profession. This growing awareness can motivate investors to put pressure on regulators to demand for better transparency and quality metrics, helping us make informed decisions in the future.
The presentation was followed by a panel discussion that included Matthew Orsagh and Mary Leung from CFA Institute, as well as industry practitioners, including Hardik Shah, ESG practice lead at GMO LLC, and Kanol Pal, senior advisor on Responsible Investments at BNP Paribas Wealth Management.
Following is a summary of the key points that emerged during the discussion.
ESG Disclosures in Asia Pacific
The Asia Pacific region has generally lagged its European counterparts in terms of ESG disclosures. Over the past few years, however, the exchanges and regulators have introduced new regulations to disclose sustainability performance, helping investors to engage more with companies on issues such as decarbonisation and human rights. For instance, regulators increasingly have been using a “comply-or-explain” approach that requires companies to either comply with regulations or explain publicly why they do not. This allows the market to decide whether the set of standards is appropriate for the companies in question. That said, it remains difficult to apply the EU taxonomy — a framework to help investors assess sustainable economic activities — because of its strict criteria that can be applied only as the markets develop over the period.
Making Sense of ESG Information
It is difficult to consume and make sense of the plethora of information available. One way to address this problem is to focus on only those ESG issues that are material to a company, rather than focusing on traditional ESG scores. This approach allows investors to evaluate only those risks that are financially important to a company. Industry groups, such as the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), have made great strides in mapping material issues to a given industry. Nevertheless, investors should not analyse ESG information in isolation. It is still important to focus on financial information to evaluate whether a sustainable company is overvalued.
Another important point that was raised during the discussion is whether the convergence of ESG standards is realistic. It also is important to realise that industry groups, such as SASB, the Global Reporting Initiative, and the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), provide complementary tools. For instance, TCFD focuses on climate-related disclosures, whereas SASB primarily addresses the needs of investors. Hence, it is incumbent upon the stakeholders to understand which tool is more relevant. But the institutions do understand the complexity surrounding sustainability disclosures. As a result, five such organisations have started working together to develop a comprehensive corporate reporting solution.
The Relevance of Environmental, Social, and Governance Issues
In the past, investors generally considered governance to be the most important aspect among the three ESG factors, whereas environment and social issues were limited to values-based investing. This is no longer the case, however, as investors have realised the importance of economic value and moral values that environment and social factors present for long-term investors. This easily can be seen in the latest ESG disclosure requirements as the world is striving towards a sustainable future.
The webinar concluded with a subject on how climate change will affect future jobs. The next generation needs to acknowledge the fact that climate-related risks are here to stay, opening doors to various opportunities across different industries. To that extent, the technology sector will see huge investments in renewable energy for managing energy-intensive data centres, whereas coal, oil, and gas industries may encounter issues in terms of future job opportunities.
About the Author(s)
Mary is the Head, Advocacy, Asia Pacific at CFA Institute. She leads the team that is responsible for building market integrity in APAC by developing and advocating capital markets policy positions that raises investor protection and fosters sustainable industry growth. She also oversees the promotion and development of Asia-Pacific Research Exchange (ARX), a research hub through which we engage with societies, members, governments, regulators, academia and other industry stakeholders 6o advance the wider CFA Institute mission.
Mary has over 20 years of experience in the global financial industry, having worked in corporate finance, wealth management advisory, and fund management. She joined Coutts & Co, where she was director of Business Development and Management for North Asia. Prior to that she was executive director at UBS AG, where she led the Corporate Advisory Group in Hong Kong. With experience in both the buy- and sell-sides, Mary has a strong understanding of the drivers and dynamics of different investor groups, including institutional investors, corporates, family offices, asset owners, and high-net-worth individuals.
Mary graduated from Peterhouse, Cambridge with a degree in Engineering. She is a CFA charterholder and speaks English, Putonghua, and Cantonese.
Matthew Orsagh, CFA, CIPM, is a senior policy analyst for the CFA Centre for Financial Market Integrity, where he serves as spokesperson for the CFA Centre, identifies and develops new corporate disclosure project ideas, and promulgates Capital Markets Policy Group corporate disclosure positions, policies, and standards. Previously, Mr. Orsagh served as a research analyst at Governance Metrics International. He has appeared on CNN's In the Money and National Public Radio's All Things Considered. Mr. Orsagh holds a BA in communications and English from the University of Notre Dame and an MBA in finance from Georgia State University.
Mr. Shah leads the ESG practice at GMO and is responsible for building GMO’s ESG capability across investment product areas and asset classes. He was a member of the CFA Institute’s inaugural global ESG working group (FY20) which aimed to develop an industry standard for the classification and disclosure of ESG investment products and has subsequently been selected as a member of its ESG verification subcommittee (FY21). Prior to joining GMO in 2017, he led a global team of analysts focused on ESG ratings and thematic research at Sustainalytics. Previously, he was an ESG Ratings associate at MSCI and, as a senior climate change consultant with Ernst & Young, has helped register a wide variety of projects with the UNFCCC under the Clean Development Mechanism defined in the Kyoto Protocol. During 2015 and 2016, Mr. Shah was voted #1 “research firm analyst who understands the challenges & opportunities facing companies” in the global Independent Research in Responsible Investment (IRRI) Survey. He earned his Bachelor of Engineering in Electronics from University of Mumbai and holds a post-graduate diploma in management - e business (finance) from We School, Mumbai. Mr. Shah holds the Fundamentals of Sustainability Accounting (FSA) credential issued by SASB, Sustainability and Climate Risk (SCR) credential by GARP, and the CFA charter.
Kanol Pal is Senior Advisor on Responsible Investments for BNP Paribas Wealth Management Asia. He has been appointed to this role in 2017 to define the Sustainable and Responsible Investments offer and to set up the SRI product platform across all asset classes for high net worth individuals. Kanol has more than 30 years experience in the financial industry having worked as Bank Treasury Manager, Head of Fixed Income & Derivatives Sales and Head of Investment Services in Singapore and Europe. He has also volunteered for various leadership positions at CFA Singapore and CFA Institute. Kanol is a graduate of ESSEC business school and a CFA charterholder. He has a post graduate certificate in Business Sustainability Management from the Cambridge Institute for Sustainability Leadership.